Site icon The News Chronicle

Chief Judge appointment: Odinkalu advocates adherence to seniority as key to preserving judicial independence

Renowned rights activist, Prof Chidi Odinkalu has accused Chairman of the Senate Committee on the South East Development Commission (SEDC), Chief Orji Uzor Kalu of attempting to rip of the Commission under the false pretense of legislative oversight. Odinkalu was reacting to a letter from the Senate Committee requesting for an interactive meeting with the SEDC Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer, Mr Mark Okoye and other management staff of the Commission, on the 9th of June 2026. According to the letter obtained by the News Chronicle, the Committee had also requested the Commission to submit the hard and soft copies of its audited reports and audited accounts to the Senate Committee. But, in a post on his official X page, Odinkalu accused Kalu of harassing the Commission under the false pretense of oversight, just to raise funds for his election campaign expenses. He expressed worry that the Committee was requesting for the hard and soft copies of the Commission’s accounts when it had not put in the work to ensure that the Commission is adequately funded. According to him, what is going on with the Commission and the Committee is the kind of terrible things that are possible when a character as Kalu occupies serious positions of public trust and significance. “That is where we are with the Committee on the SEDC in the Senate. That is why we must retire Kalu. “It is election season and Kalu wants the Commission to fund his election rigging expenses. So, he is harassing the Commission under the false pretense of oversight. “This letter from the Committee to the Commission is not even worth a teaspoonful of warm spittle. “It is interesting that Kalu is asking for hard and soft copies of the entrails of the SEDC. But they are not interested in how much the Committee has received or when,” he said. Odinkalu revealed that for the first nine months after it was inaugurated in February 2025, the SEDC received nothing in terms of the promised funds, adding that till date, the Commission has received zero Naira of Capital Expenditure. According to him, in Dec 2025, the Commission eventually received a take-off grant of N5m, an information that is in the public domain. He noted that as a long-serving public office holder, Kalu ought to understand how Ministry, Departments and Agencies, MDAs are audited, and as such, should know the position of the SEDC. “Kalu has been long enough in public office to know the calendar of audits of Ministries, Departments and Agencies, MDAs. He knows that the SEDC has yet to be audited by the Auditor-General. But he is asking for audit reports and audited accounts. “The Senate, of which Kalu is a principal officer, says Nigeria should operate three budgets. The SEDC has 2 unfunded budgets. Instead of helping to get the funds of the Commission released, Kalu wants to turn the Commission into an object of Parliamentary striptease. “And the way this reads, he has arranged to put this into the media in order to set the Commission up for blackmail. “The goal is clear: he wants a share of the take-off grant and of any recurrent funds that the Commission gets. And he cannot hide it. “We don't need such characters in public life. Retire Orji Uzor Kalu now,” he said.

Nigerian Human Rights Activist Prof Chidi Odinkalu

Former Chairman of the National Human Rights Commission, NHRC, Prof. Chidi Odinkalu, has cautioned against what he described as the growing politicisation of the office of the Chief Judge in Nigeria, referencing the ongoing controversy surrounding the appointment of a substantive Chief Judge for Imo State.

Citing India’s famous Kesavananda Bharati case, which triggered a constitutional crisis over judicial appointments in the 1970s, Odinkalu argued that adherence to the convention of seniority is essential to preserving judicial independence and insulating the process from political interference.

According to him, the convention of appointing the most senior judge as head of a court system evolved to ensure transparency, prevent partisan manipulation and protect judges from being denied elevation on the basis of unsubstantiated allegations.

He traced Nigeria’s judicial history, noting that although seniority became entrenched in the appointment of Chief Justices after 1979, political considerations had progressively eroded the authority and prestige of state chief judges.

Odinkalu recalled instances in which military and civilian administrations allegedly sought to influence judicial appointments, including the removal of former Anambra State Chief Judge, Emmanuel Araka, under the military regime and the prolonged vacancy in the office of the Rivers State Chief Judge during the administration of former governor Rotimi Amaechi.

On the situation in Imo State, Odinkalu noted that the state has been without a substantive Chief Judge for nearly 20 months following the removal of the last occupant of the office by the National Judicial Council (NJC) over age falsification in November 2024.

He recalled that the NJC in April 2025 rejected an attempt by Governor Hope Uzodinma to bypass the three most senior judges in the state in appointing an Acting Chief Judge and subsequently directed that the most senior judge, Justice Ijeoma Ogugua, be appointed in an acting capacity.

“Justice Ogugua, who was appointed to the High Court bench in 1993, had served for 33 years and had twice been overlooked for the office despite being senior to the next judge by 11 years.

“There is everything wrong with the decision of the Imo State Judicial Service Commission (JSC) to publish a shortlist of two judges for public comments without including the Acting Chief Judge. The commission lacks constitutional powers to recommend candidates and is only empowered to advise the NJC on suitable nominees.

“The omission appeared designed to exclude Justice Ogugua from consideration, and allegations of inducement and coercion had also trailed the exercise,” he noted.

Odinkalu further accused the Imo State Governor of branding the three most senior judges in the state as “not appointable” while failing to subject the allegations against them to formal investigation by the NJC.

He maintained that Justice Ogugua has no adverse disciplinary record with the council and urged the Chief Justice of Nigeria to uphold established judicial conventions and safeguard the independence of the judiciary.

“The Chief Justice of Nigeria has an opportunity to define the applicable conventions. It is not her job to grant the governor a Chief Judge whom he can own,” Odinkalu said.
Exit mobile version