Site icon The News Chronicle

People Have Their Life To Live: When Gratitude Becomes Ownership In Kano

Nigeria's University Boom Without Pattern or Consistency?

Bagudu Mohammed

While the world is in search of reason, of grievance that can possibly make a sitting First Lady of the most populous and prosperous Kano denounce love for her husband after twenty years and having six children, a social media post tries to provide a clue, whether rightly or wrongly.

It reads in Hausa and translated to English thus:

“inna lillahi, Allah sarki, Aunty Zainab, in 1993 it was your father who appointed him as a Personal Assistant, in 1999 while your father was Governor he appointed him again as a Local Government Personal Assistant, from 2003 to 2007 when your father was Minister of Defence he appointed him as a Special Assistant, in 2006 he gave him a position at your wedding, from 2007 to 2009 while your father was at the NDDC he again appointed him as a Special Assistant, when your father became Ambassador and Special Envoy to Darfur in Sudan he again appointed him as a Special Assistant.

It reads further: in 2011 when your father returned as Governor he appointed him as Principal Private Secretary, in 2013 he appointed him as a Commissioner, in 2015 he asked Ganduje to appoint him as Deputy Governor but Ganduje refused, in 2019 he picked him as his preferred candidate for Governor, he won but Ganduje and his camp allegedly took the victory away from him, in 2023 he once again backed him for the governorship and this time they succeeded”

In addition ” in 2024 he fell out with your father, in 2025 he destroyed your father’s political party, in 2026 Teemacool was reportedly given a huge sum of money for insulting your father, in 2026 Salisu Yahaya Hotoro was elevated for insulting your father, in 2026 Rahama Fagge was elevated for insulting your father, in 2026 Sunusi Nature of Dawakin Tofa was elevated for insulting your father, and you watched all this happen before your very eyes yet you remained patient out of respect for the sanctity and dignity of marriage, you have been hurt, you have been treated unjustly, your trust has been betrayed, may Allah reward you and grant you justice, but whatever happens you have truly proved yourself to be a woman of good character and noble upbringing, it was your father who gave him a house and a car, yet it is you who is owed by him, and I swear by Allah he will surely repay that debt.”

True, I was touched and drawn into deep emotions before recovery, because the post does not read like politics, it reads like a wound, like a daughter being told to count the favours her father poured on her husband, as if love were an account book, as if marriage were a contract of eternal repayment, and for a moment even the most hardened observer feels the sting of betrayal, the ache of watching a benefactor become a rival, a son-in-law become a stranger, a husband become an accused man in his own home.

I think if those reasons are enough to justify divorce it still felt like confirming weakness from both sides, or guilt, because divorce in this story is not merely a private decision between husband and wife, it is a public verdict on loyalty, on gratitude, on who owes whom, and on whether a man who was lifted from Personal Assistant to Governor can ever be free to disagree with the hand that lifted him, and whether a woman caught between father and husband can ever be free to love both without being accused of betraying one.

People must realize that loyalty in life cannot be achieved from people 100% and we cannot also give 100% loyalty to anyone to trust because they have their life to live, and Zainab cannot tell anyone that she is 100% loyal to her parents or husband, sometimes their interests differ, she also has children and many parents cannot say that the children are 100% loyal to the extent that they comply with choices made for them about life on everything.

By the time we begin to look at life as because of what we do for people they do not have right to disobey or differ in interest, betrayal becomes inevitable, and this is where Marcel Mauss, the French sociologist who studied the gift, becomes painfully relevant, for Mauss argued in his classic theory of gift exchange that every gift creates an obligation to return, and in traditional societies that obligation can become a chain, a debt that never ends, and when the giver expects total obedience as repayment, the gift stops being generosity and becomes control, and what looks like ingratitude may in fact be a desperate attempt to breathe.

I believe this high expectation on the side of one party that he owes gratitude and lifetime loyalty to one who made him is the culprit, for the truth is people must live or struggle to live their life independently as a matter of survival or self preservation, and this is not an excuse for betrayal if it is right to use the word, or rather failed expectations, but it is human nature that is not capable of being loyal to even God Almighty 100% by the way we sin despite all He has done for us.

This is rather about helping or building people not necessarily to control or remote-control and expect absolute loyalty and lifelong submission, but instead to be modest in sustaining enduring relationship, and here Abraham Maslow speaks again with quiet force, for in his hierarchy of needs he placed self-actualisation, the need to become oneself, above mere belonging, which means that even the most loved protégé, the most favoured son-in-law, the most obedient wife, will one day hunger to be more than an extension of another person’s will.

The research in social psychology has consistently shown that relationships built on indebtedness rather than autonomy breed resentment, passive resistance and eventual rupture, because humans do not thrive when they are treated as investments waiting for dividends.

I do not know how people like Atiku view his own son in the APC campaigning against him after giving birth to him, is that up to what Kwankwaso did for Governor Abba Yusuf, and that question alone exposes the tragedy, for if a father cannot command 100% loyalty from the son he created, how can a political godfather command 100% loyalty from a man he merely appointed?

And, if even prophets wept over the disobedience of their own followers, how can any mortal expect that gratitude will buy obedience forever, and perhaps the real lesson of Kano is not that Abba betrayed Kwankwaso, or that Zainab betrayed Abba, or that Kwankwaso betrayed gratitude, but that we have mistaken help for ownership, and loyalty for slavery, and until we learn that people have their life to live, that a wife is not a referee between father and husband, that a governor is not a property of his maker, that a daughter is not a debt collector for her father’s favours, we will continue to turn every disagreement into betrayal, every independence into ingratitude, and every marriage into a battlefield where love itself becomes the first casualty.

 

bagudumohammed15197@gmail.com

07034943575

Bagudu Mohammed is the founder of Alternative Perspectives, a widely read commentary platform on social media. It offers evidence-based analysis and real-life insights as a credible alternative to groupthink, convenient narratives, and echo chambers. The platform explores a wide range of issues, including politics, society, relationships, governance, and contemporary trends.

Web: https://alternativeperspective.onrender.com

Exit mobile version