spot_img
spot_imgspot_img
November 16, 2026 - 6:52 AM

Court Reserves Judgment in Suit Challenging Lawan’s APC Senatorial Candidacy

—

The Federal High Court in Abuja on Monday reserved judgment in a suit seeking to nullify the emergence of former Senate President Ahmad Lawan as the All Progressives Congress (APC) candidate for Yobe North Senatorial District in the 2027 general elections.

Justice Salim Ibrahim said the date for delivering the judgment would be communicated to the parties 24 hours before delivery.

The judge made this known after lawyers representing the parties adopted their processes and presented arguments for and against the suit.

Image Credit – Web

Counsel to the plaintiff, Hassan Kafayos, Francis Mgboh, urged the court to grant the reliefs sought, citing a Supreme Court decision which, he said, established that issues relating to candidate nomination in elections were governed by constitutional provisions.

Mgboh argued that Lawan did not participate in the APC primary election scheduled for May 18, insisting that the former Senate president neither purchased a nomination form for the senatorial seat nor emerged through a valid primary.

He maintained that the election was scheduled for May 18, not May 20, and argued that the process was conducted under a repealed law.

The lawyer consequently urged the court to declare Kafayos the duly nominated candidate of the party for the senatorial district.

However, APC counsel, Adedayo Adedeji, SAN, and Lawan’s lawyer, Shaibu Aruwa, SAN, opposed the plaintiff’s arguments.

Adedeji said the party had filed a preliminary objection challenging the court’s jurisdiction to hear the suit.

He urged the court to dismiss the case with substantial costs, describing it as an abuse of court process.

The senior lawyer argued that the suit was statute-barred because it was filed outside the constitutionally prescribed period.

He noted that the primary election took place in May, while the suit was instituted much later.

Adedeji also urged the court to reject a document containing questions for the cross-examination of subpoenaed witnesses, describing it as incompetent.

Abdulalim Akeem, counsel to APC National Chairman, Prof. Nentawe Yilwatda, also urged the court to dismiss the suit, while Aruwa sought N100 million in costs against the plaintiff.

Counsel to the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), P.A. Bello, aligned himself with the arguments advanced by Adedeji and Aruwa.

Bello maintained that the suit lacked merit and should not have been instituted, urging the court to dismiss it with substantial costs.

After listening to the parties, Justice Ibrahim reserved judgment to a date to be communicated to counsel.

Kafayos, an APC aspirant who challenged his exclusion from the May 18 primary election, instituted the suit against the party, Yilwatda, Lawan and INEC as the first to fourth defendants, respectively.

In his originating summons filed by Mgboh, the plaintiff sought four reliefs, including a declaration that his alleged exclusion from the primary election violated his constitutional right to freedom from discrimination under Section 42 of the 1999 Constitution.

He also alleged that the defendants’ actions breached Sections 84, 85, 86 and 87 of the Electoral Act, 2026, as well as Articles 2, 9.3 and 20 of the APC constitution.

Kafayos asked the court to restrain the APC and Yilwatda from forwarding Lawan’s name to INEC as the party’s duly nominated candidate for Yobe North Senatorial District.

He also sought an order preventing INEC from accepting or publishing Lawan’s name as the party’s candidate based on the disputed primary election.

Alternatively, he asked the court to compel the APC, Yilwatda and INEC to conduct a fresh primary or recognize him as the party’s duly nominated candidate.

The plaintiff further sought N50 million in aggravated and exemplary damages against the APC, Yilwatda and Lawan over his alleged wrongful exclusion from the primary.

In an affidavit supporting the suit, Kafayos said he was a financial member of the APC and had indicated his interest in contesting the 2027 senatorial election by purchasing and submitting an expression-of-interest form.

He said the party received his completed form on May 6 and subsequently cleared him to participate in the primary after a screening exercise.

According to him, on May 18, he waited for several hours before the party’s election committee arrived at the designated venue at the Government Lodge in Gashua, Yobe, at about 3:25 p.m.

He alleged that the committee announced, without prior notice or consultation, that only Lawan had been cleared to contest the election, despite his earlier clearance by the party’s screening committee.

Kafayos claimed the announcement triggered confusion among voters, who allegedly chanted his nickname, “Iroko”, in support of his candidacy.

He further alleged that members of the election committee, with Lawan’s support, deployed police officers to fire tear gas at the venue to disperse those gathered for the direct primary.

The plaintiff maintained that no valid direct or consensus primary was conducted at the designated venue because the crowd had been dispersed.

He alleged that he later discovered through social media that the election committee had moved from the Government Lodge to Lawan’s private residence in Gashua, where about seven people reportedly affirmed the former Senate president as the party’s candidate.

Kafayos argued that the process undermined the APC’s internal democratic procedures and violated electoral guidelines.

He said photographs purportedly showing Lawan’s affirmation at the private residence were printed and attached to his court processes as evidence.

The aspirant added that he had attempted to resolve the dispute through the party’s internal administrative channels by submitting a written complaint to the APC State Chairman’s Appeal Committee in Damaturu on May 18.

He urged the court to nullify the disputed primary and order a fresh election, citing alleged lack of transparency and breaches of democratic procedures.

Alternatively, he asked the court to disqualify Lawan and declare him the duly nominated candidate for the senatorial district.

READ ALSO: Court Jails Woman Five Years for Supplying 500 AK-47 Bullets to Bandits

However, Lawan, the APC and Yilwatda urged the court to dismiss the suit in their separate filings.

In his preliminary objection, Lawan challenged the court’s jurisdiction, while the APC, through Adedeji, argued that the suit was fundamentally defective and statute-barred.

Adedeji maintained that the case was filed outside the mandatory 14-day period prescribed under Section 285(14) of the 1999 Constitution, as amended, and Rule 9 of the 2022 Practice Directions.

Yilwatda, in a counter-affidavit deposed to by Lovelyn Donatus, a legal officer in the APC’s Legal Services Department, maintained that the party duly constituted a committee to conduct the senatorial primary election.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Share post:

Subscribe

Latest News

More like this
Related

Why is Shettima So Hateful of Peter Obi?

Political violence is holding the country by the jugular,...

The Unfortunate Fate Of Citizen Kadafa

The troubling insecurity across the country has remained a...

Bandits Kill Zamfara Governor’s Aide as Police Rescue 19 Kidnap Victims

Bandits have killed a Senior Special Assistant (SSA) to...

Man Dumps Fiancée, Calls Off Wedding Over APC Campaign Appearance in Akwa Ibom

A Nigerian man has reportedly called off his planned...
Join us on
For more updates, columns, opinions, etc.
WhatsApp
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x